Renovating or building is not one single decision
For both renovating and building, you may make the big initial decision to do it.
Once that decision is made though, you’ll then be making lots of smaller decisions, and making them sequentially. Each decision you make leads you step by step to your finished home. And, at each decision, you can be making it alone, or in the company of those advising you – be it your team, your builder, your friends and family, or your salesperson.
It’s these decisions – and the quantity and potential impact of them – that can overwhelm most homeowners.
It doesn’t take a lot to make 3 or 4 wrong turns – or take bad advice from well-meaning people – and end up a long way from where you’re supposed to be.
You’ll spend time. You’ll spend money. And you’ll be in a position you don’t want to be. Putting up with terrible service, terrible quality, terrible results.
And because you’ve spent time and money getting there, what I often see is this reaction.
“It’s OK. I’ve already spent this time and money. I don’t want to start again. And everyone has problems when renovating or building – this is no different to the norm.”
Or, it might be something like this …
“Well, it’s not exactly what I want. But I don’t want to hurt their feelings, or be the difficult customer, or put them off side.”
Like fearing the waiter who spits in our soup if we complain, we can be the same with those helping us build or renovate our homes.
From the outside – with some perspective – we can see others in this scenario, and can easily say “I never would have let it get that bad. I would have left ages ago. I would have spoken up.” The luxury of it not being us is a ticket to objectivity.
Yet, inside the scenario, it’s not so simple. When it’s our home, it’s something we’ve not done before, and it’s lots of dollars and time, it can be easy to fall further and further into the rabbit hole.
All the while consoling ourselves that going elsewhere would only mean another rabbit hole. Better the devil you know hey?
SOOOO …. What do you do when this is you?
Stop.
Stop putting up with being treated poorly. Stop accepting crappy service, and bad quality work.
One of my favourite sayings is “The standard you walk past is the standard you accept.” (said by Lieutenant General David Lindsay Morrison AO, the Chief of Army).
This is the thing.
Whilst any one of us lets ourselves be subjected to … and pays for … bad service, bad quality materials, bad building – we say it’s ok.
While any one of us says “but this is just what happens when you build or renovate”, we let it be what exactly happens when you build or renovate. We actually enable it.
And whilst we say “but I don’t want to hurt their feelings”, we say that the feelings of the person we are paying to provide a professional service (that we possibly didn’t even meet before we commissioned them for this service), are more important than us getting what we deserve, what we’ve paid for, and what we were led to believe we’d be given.
This is the kicker …
What’s the BIG reason that we stay? Well, I think the hardest thing is admitting we made the wrong choice. That we were wrong. That – I think – is usually the biggest hurdle.
When I read this quote from Danielle La Porte, it sums this up perfectly.
“Don’t worry about how you’re going to fix what’s broke. Just notice what sucks with ruthless honesty.
It’ll be a momentary rush when you do. You might even feel a strange sense of elation. I Know It Sucks Euphoria. And when you’re high on the truth, you’ve got a new vantage point of where to go to next. Turn the lights off when you leave.
Announce your new destination.”
This post may sound super dramatic to you
However, I’ve seen it so frequently … homeowners, with their hearts on their sleeves, mortgages in their pockets and dreams in their minds, getting so poorly treated. And not walking away.
OK so you want to leave? Say no? Here’s what to do.
Anticipate worst case scenario
Go into every relationship and contract imagining the worst case scenario, and understand the consequences. Will you get your money back? Will you own the work you’ve done together? Will you owe anymore money?
Don’t be worried about looking like an idiot
Chances are it’s the first time you’ve done this, and even the most seasoned experts make mistakes and poor choices. Recognising the mistake and changing it is the smarter choice.
Don’t let the fear of hurting someone’s feelings stop you
I’m not promoting you be unkind. It’s just that when it’s about bad service, or bad treatment, it’s not personal. It’s about what someone does – not who someone is. I’ve seen time and time again (and have helped facilitate it) homeowners having difficult conversations with builders. Expressing their dissatisfaction in one moment (and resolving it) and then moving on to talk jovially about plans for the weekend. It’s not personal if you don’t personally attack them. Talk about the work, the service, not the person.
Know your rights at all times
If things do go pear-shaped, check your legal agreements, and those that exist under any governing bodies. Go in fully armed with knowing what your rights are, should you need to exert them.
Collect evidence
Put everything in writing. If things start to go south, document the journey. Build a paper trail. Conversations, meetings, phonecalls, instructions given and not followed. Write it all down.
Can I please speak to your manager?
If possible, move up the chain. Speak to management, or the head office, if you’re not getting love or traction locally.
Don’t throw good money after bad
Be prepared to cut your losses and walk away. In situations like this, you’re rarely starting from scratch when you start again. You’ll be able to move forward making decisions faster, and more clearly. Yes, you may lose some money. It sucks. But weigh it up against the overall investment you’re making. Often I see homeowners grappling with walking away from $10,000 of mistaken spending, in the big picture of a $400,000 spend overall. It’s a chunk of money, but proportionally, your overall investment means so much more is at jeopardy.
It may hurt a little to make the decision to leave, to change things, to say ‘no’.
What will hurt a lot more though?
Staying.
Not only for you, your experience, and your home …
But also for every other person who comes after you along the same journey.
Because how do we improve things?
With one homeowner at a time – demanding better. If not you, then who?
Other blogs you may find useful …
Worried about your architect blowing your budget? Here’s 12 tips about what to do …
How to have the first conversation with your designer without feeling like a fool.
This is how you can avoid a bad design for your project.
Tina Lissette says
Excellent post Amelia. Well said. Should be required reading for anyone building or renovating. ☺
Amelia says
Hi Tina!
Thanks so much for your kind comment – I’m glad you enjoyed the post. As you could probably tell, it’s something I feel very passionately about!
– Amelia, UA x
Rachelle says
I am reading all your posts with great interest. We have been burned before and with some trepidation we are considering a renovation again. What I worry about is that in these cases they really do know “where you live”.
Amelia says
Hey Rachelle,
They do! I hope the Undercover Architect website and podcast helps you get ready for your renovation so you can be better protected next time.
– Amelia, UA
Mumof2g says
We engaged a local well-known drafter with a reputation for being really creative. She did a great job in designing a renovation & extension with all of the things we wanted. Job done – we paid her.
Now after some consultation with our chosen builder we’ve decided the change a few minor things that will bring down the overall cost significantly. I desperately need her to make the changes so we can get on with the structural drawings and final contracts. I’ve spent close to 5 weeks attempting to contact her through phone call, emails, text messages without any solid response. Two vague text messages saying I’ll do it soon. She refuses to even give me an estimate for the extra work saying it’s too hard to figure out!!!!
We feel so powerless and stuck in this situation. Not sure what else I can do other than continue to leave pleasant messages asking for her to please call me. It’s just maddening, I wish I’d never used her.
Amelia says
Megan, that is very frustrating. Unfortunately, because she’s a drafter, there’s no governing body she needs to be accountable to, that you could report her to. Perhaps being firm, and visiting her office in person, may be the next options available to you. Alternatively, ask her to hand over electronic versions of the drawings so you can continue work with someone else (dwg files, which can be opened in various CAD software) if she’s not able to assist you. The engineer will generally request dwg files as part of doing their work anyway. Wishing you the best in getting things sorted.
– Amelia, UA
Mumof2g says
Thanks Amelia. A politely worded ultimatum seems to have worked – we now have updated pdfs, and are waiting on the dwg files to be sent to engineer.
Amelia says
Well done – that’s awesome news 🙂 Best wishes with progressing your project!
– Amelia, UA
TM says
The governing body comment is interesting. We are building and have a designer (not architect – though he does have an degree in architecture). Happy with design etc and build going reasonably well.
One major issue – relative height for garage was wrong. He admits it was a mistake on his part. Builders build to the level on the plans, checking with surveyor as stipulated in drawing notes. Council approved the build with height as indicated. But will not approve a driveway to access it since it is too steep (as garage is too low).
End result – framing pulled down. New slab poured on top (had been well engineered) and framing up again. Cost ~12,000 but another $2k to redo the pool piping which was in the first slab.
Designer admits mistake but says builders should have noticed and checked with him.
Builders say they checked with surveyor and built to plans.
Apparently the sub contracted concreter queried to builder who said check plans again and go from that
Now I have an invoice to pay. Who is liable?
Shouldn’t be me. Though I offered to go thirds. Builder thought this reasonable. Designer said no, too much (and I didn’t even charge you that much, and my contract with you is complete and the builder is making a mint out of this build and can afford it …..) but will contribute some ($2k).
Now what??
Amelia says
Hi Tracey,
It’s a tricky situation. If the designer was a registered architect, you’d be able to call the Board of Architects and ask for their advice. If the designer is not licensed to any regulating body, it can be difficult to pursue unless you do so legally. It does sound (from your description) that the designer has admitted their error but has not been involved in the construction phase. Some designer agreements (when designer is not proceeding beyond documentation) refer liability for drawings across to the owner at point of final payment. The issue was apparently flagged to the builder, who didn’t investigate it further at the time to determine if any errors in the documentation (which can and does occur). I would actually suggest seeking some legal advice given the quantity of cost. You could start with the Master Builder’s Association in your state and go from there. Best wishes … it is a very messy situation.
– Amelia, UA